Comparing options
Compare options against criteria you set first, build a weighted scorecard, and make Claude argue the other side.
-
How Do You Test a Recommendation From Claude? After Claude recommends an option, ask what would have to be different for it to recommend something else, and which single fact the choice depends on most. Level 3: Workflowshow much the choice rests on it →Check this firstthe choice can flip on itRely on itchecked and decisiveNote it, move onunchecked but minorIgnore itchecked and minorhow well checked the fact is →
-
How Do You Build a Weighted Decision Scorecard With Claude? Ask Claude to build the scorecard as an Excel file with live formulas, and set the weights yourself. Level 3: Workflows100points
- Integration with payroll40
- Price30
- Migration effort20
- Support10
-
How Do You Compare Options With Claude Fairly? Write down your criteria before Claude sees the options, then ask it to fill in a table with evidence for each cell. Level 2: ContextUpload to a chatyou already have the sources
- Quotes, contracts, reports
- Fixes the evidence in advance
- Up to 20 files per chat
Researchyou still need the sources- Searches many pages
- Takes a few minutes or more
- Paid plans, uses limits faster
-
How Do You Get Claude to Argue Against Your Decision? Tell Claude which way you're leaning, then give it one job: make the strongest honest case for the other option, with evidence. Level 3: WorkflowsDo
- Say which way you lean
- Ask for the best opposing case
- Ask when the alternative wins
- Require sources you can open
Don't- Ask "any downsides?"
- Accept a case with no evidence
- Reuse the chat that built your case
Set the terms, then bring evidence
Write your criteria before Claude sees the options, and make every table cell carry a link or page number. If you don't have sources yet, use Research. Anthropic's Sonnet 5.5 guide warns the model sometimes answers from training when a search would catch changed details such as what's charged, so tell Claude to check prices and terms against current sources.
Then push on the result
A comparison is a starting point. Build a scorecard in a real spreadsheet to see how weights affect the ranking, ask what would change the recommendation, and have Claude argue for the option you didn't pick. Each step gives you something specific to verify, and the verifying is yours to do.
How do I compare two documents with Claude?
Attach both in one chat, using the + button and Add files or photos, and name the criteria to compare them on. Ask for a table with page numbers. For PDFs with charts, keep each to 100 pages or fewer, because longer ones are read as text only.
Can Claude make a comparison spreadsheet?
Yes. With Code execution and file creation on, Claude can create an Excel file you download. Ask for live formulas and editable weights, so you can change a weight and watch the totals update. Anthropic says file creation uses your limits faster than regular chat.
Should I use Research or web search to compare products?
Use Research to compare several options across many sources, which Anthropic's Academy lists as a typical use. Use web search for one quick fact, such as a single vendor's price. Research is on paid plans and can use your limits faster.
Can I trust Claude's recommendation?
Treat it as a draft. Ask what assumptions it depends on, and which single fact would change it, then verify that fact yourself. Anthropic notes that its methods for reducing errors don't eliminate them, and that critical information should always be validated.