What Is Inclusive Design?

Inclusive design asks who a product leaves out, designs for them first, and finds that the result is better for the people it never left out either. The curb cut is the standard example, and it still holds.

What Is Inclusive Design? — Troiana insight cover

In short

Inclusive design is a methodology that designs for the full range of human diversity by starting with the people who are most often excluded, recognising that exclusion is a mismatch between a person and a design rather than a property of the person, and that solving for one excluded group extends to many. It is broader than accessibility, which is the compliance floor, and more practical than universal design, which seeks one solution for all; it produces a set of solutions and options. Microsoft's inclusive design toolkit, with its permanent, temporary and situational spectrum, is the widely used framework.

The idea

Every design decision includes some people and excludes others. A tap that needs a strong grip excludes people with arthritis, and also anyone carrying shopping. Small grey text excludes people with low vision, and also anyone in sunlight. A video without captions excludes deaf viewers, and also everyone on a train. Inclusive design treats these exclusions as design mismatches rather than as user deficiencies, and it starts the design process with the people on the wrong side of the mismatch.

The curb cut is the canonical example: the ramp cut into a kerb for wheelchair users, which turned out to serve parents with pushchairs, delivery workers with trolleys, cyclists, travellers with luggage and everyone else. Designing for the excluded case produced the better general design. Inclusive design is the practice of looking for that effect deliberately.

The three principles

Microsoft's inclusive design toolkit, published in 2016 and now the most widely referenced framework, states them:

Recognise exclusion. Notice where a design assumes an ability, a device, a context, a language or a level of knowledge that not everyone has. Bias is usually unconscious and the design reflects its makers.

Learn from diversity. People who adapt to a world not designed for them are experts in adaptation. Involving them in research and design reveals problems and solutions the team cannot see.

Solve for one, extend to many. A solution designed for a specific excluded group, done well, benefits a far larger group with related needs in other circumstances.

The spectrum

The toolkit's most useful tool is the persona spectrum. For any ability, there are people for whom the limitation is permanent (one arm), temporary (an arm injury), and situational (a new parent holding a baby). Design for the permanent case and the solution serves the temporary and situational cases, which are far more numerous. One-handed operation of a phone interface, designed for the first group, is used constantly by the third.

The spectrum turns accessibility from a minority concern into a majority one: at any moment a large share of any audience is in a temporary or situational condition that a design either accommodates or does not.

PermanentTemporarySituational
TouchOne armArm injuryHolding a new baby
SeeBlindCataractDistracted driver
HearDeafEar infectionNoisy bar
The persona spectrum from Microsoft's inclusive design toolkit. Solve for one, and you extend to many.

Inclusive design, accessibility, universal design

Accessibility is the compliance floor: the WCAG criteria, the legal requirements, the checklist. It is necessary and it is measurable, and it is the outcome of inclusive design rather than its method.

Universal design, from architecture, seeks a single solution that works for everyone without adaptation. It is a good aspiration and often impossible; some needs conflict.

Inclusive design is the process: research with excluded people, design for their needs, and produce solutions and options rather than a single one, so that people can choose what suits them. It includes accessibility and usually exceeds it, and it accepts that one size will not fit all.

The argument that accessibility is not a feature is the inclusive design argument stated from the other side.

Practising it

Research with the excluded. Recruit participants with disabilities, older participants, people with low literacy or a second language, people on old devices and slow connections. Their sessions find what average users cannot.

Write the spectrum for each key interaction. Who cannot see this, hear this, hold this, understand this, afford the data for this? What would serve the permanent case?

Offer options, not one path. Captions and transcripts, keyboard and touch, light and dark, text and audio, simple and detailed. Let people choose their adaptation.

Design the edges first. The error state, the slow connection, the small screen, the screen reader, the colour-blind palette. If they work, the middle works.

Test with assistive technology and constrained conditions, not only with the team's devices.

Use the language of the people you are designing for, and let them review it.

Measure exclusion: who abandons, who fails tasks, who contacts support, broken down by the conditions you can observe.

The business case

The excluded are numerous: around one in six people worldwide have a significant disability, most people have a temporary or situational limitation at any given time, and populations are ageing. Designs that serve them serve more customers, reduce support costs, meet legal obligations, and are generally clearer, faster and more robust. The features people cite as best in class, captions, dark mode, voice input, one-handed layouts, readable type, began as inclusive solutions. Inclusive design is not a cost added to a product; it is the method by which the best general-purpose products were made.

If you would like an inclusive design review of a product, with research participants from the groups it currently serves worst, book a call.

Common questions

What is the difference between inclusive design and accessibility?

Accessibility is the compliance floor: the WCAG criteria and legal requirements that a product must meet. Inclusive design is the method that produces accessible products and more: researching with people who are excluded, designing for their needs first, and offering options so people can choose what suits them. Accessibility is an outcome; inclusive design is the process.

What is an example of inclusive design?

The curb cut: a ramp in the kerb designed for wheelchair users that also serves parents with pushchairs, delivery workers, cyclists and travellers with luggage. In software: captions designed for deaf viewers used by everyone watching without sound, one-handed phone layouts designed for people with one arm used by anyone holding a bag.

What are the principles of inclusive design?

From Microsoft's inclusive design toolkit: recognise exclusion, noticing where a design assumes abilities or contexts not everyone has; learn from diversity, involving people who adapt to a world not built for them; and solve for one, extend to many, since a solution for a specific excluded group benefits a much larger population with related needs.

What is the persona spectrum?

A tool from Microsoft's toolkit that maps any limitation across permanent, temporary and situational cases, such as having one arm, an arm injury, and holding a baby. Designing for the permanent case produces a solution used by the far larger temporary and situational groups, which makes accessibility a majority concern.

Is inclusive design the same as universal design?

No. Universal design seeks a single solution that works for everyone without adaptation, which is often impossible because needs conflict. Inclusive design accepts that and produces a set of solutions and options, developed through research with excluded people, so that individuals can choose what works for them.

Have something worth building right?