AI Visibility Tools Compared: What Each One Measures

These tools all promise to show where you appear in AI answers. They differ most in which engines they include, how many prompts you get and how much the answers can be trusted.

AI Visibility Tools Compared: What Each One Measures — Troiana insight cover

In short

AI visibility tools run a set of prompts through AI engines and report who gets mentioned or cited. Entry prices range from $29 a month for 15 prompts on Otterly to custom enterprise contracts. Check engine coverage closely, because popular engines can be add-ons or restricted to top tiers. Start with a free manual test of 20–30 prompts, and only buy when that becomes too slow to repeat.

What these tools really do

Almost all of them follow the same process: you give them prompts, they run those prompts through AI engines on a schedule, and they report mentions, citations, your share compared with competitors, and sometimes sentiment. Some add audits, content advice or tracking of AI crawlers on your site.

That's useful, but understand what it is. These tools sample answers to prompts you chose. They are not showing you what real customers typed or saw, because AI vendors do not publish that data the way Google Search Console does for search. For the wider method, read how to measure whether AI engines are citing you.

The comparison

From vendor pricing pages on 4 November 2026, unless marked. Plans change frequently, and some vendors don't publish all their prices.

ToolEntry pricePrompts at entryEngines
Otterly$29/month15ChatGPT, AI Overviews, Perplexity, Copilot; AI Mode, Gemini and Claude are paid add-ons
Peec AI$95/month50ChatGPT, AI Mode, AI Overviews, Copilot, Gemini, Naver; up to 3 active models; Perplexity and Claude on Enterprise
Ahrefs Brand RadarCustom Prompts from $50/month; Index from $199/month5 custom prompts on LiteAI Overviews, AI Mode, ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Copilot; Claude on Custom Prompts
ProfoundFree 7-day trial; Enterprise is custom50 on trialUp to 9 on Enterprise, including ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Mode, Claude and DeepSeek
SemrushReported by third parties at about $99/month as an add-onVariesNot listed on the page we checked

Some numbers deserve a closer look:

  • Otterly's add-ons: adding Claude costs $29 on Lite and rises to $439 on Premium, so its true price depends on which engines you need.
  • Peec's model limit: its self-serve plans track up to three active models at a time, so you have to choose among them.
  • Ahrefs: Claude uses more checks, at 8 per update. Its page says Prompt Tracking is free on paid Ahrefs plans from Lite upwards, which could be sufficient if you are already a customer.

How to choose

Begin with the engines your buyers use. A tool that's strong on engines your customers ignore isn't helpful. Ask a few recent customers, and check your AI referral traffic to see where any visits come from.

Count your prompts honestly. Estimate what you need: say, 10 important questions across 3 buying stages, with a few variations. Fifteen prompts could suit one product, but it won't go far for a business with several services or locations.

Work out the cost per prompt per engine. Headline prices are hard to compare, as limits differ so widely. Divide cost by prompts, then add the cost of any extra engines.

Check how often prompts run, and how many times. AI answers vary from run to run. A single daily sample can swing considerably, so one change in a report may not mean much.

Decide if you need advice or only data. Some tools report; others add audits and recommendations. Be wary of automatic recommendations presented as guaranteed wins, since nobody outside these companies knows exactly how their systems rank sources.

Look at the data exports. If you plan to analyse results yourself, confirm you can get them out. Otterly lists an API and MCP access from Standard, for example.

Entry price per prompt, per month
Otterly: $29 for 15 prompts$1.93
Peec AI: $95 for 50 prompts$1.90
$0$1$2$3
Calculated from the pricing above, before add-ons and engine limits, which is where the plans really differ.

What the numbers cannot tell you

  • Real demand. Prompt lists are guesses at how people ask, and real questions are often much longer and more specific.
  • Personalisation. Your results may differ from a customer's, depending on memory, location and account.
  • Causation. If visibility goes up after a content update, the model or the sampling could also have changed.
  • Revenue. A mention in an answer is not a customer. Connect this to your enquiries where possible, including by asking new leads how they found you.

Treat these tools as directional trend lines, and be careful when a vendor offers precise-looking scores.

Try the free version first

Before paying, spend an hour on this:

  1. Write 20–30 questions that a real buyer might ask.
  2. Run each three times in a clean session of ChatGPT, Google AI Mode, Perplexity and any other engine your customers use.
  3. Record in a spreadsheet whether you were mentioned, whether you were linked, and who else appeared.
  4. Note which pages get cited. They often show what's missing from your content.
  5. Repeat every month.

This reveals more about your position than most dashboards do in the first month, and you will end up with a better prompt list if you do buy a tool later. Move to paid tracking when repeating this becomes a chore, or if you need a lot of prompts, several markets or client reports.

And none of these tools will fix anything for you. If you find gaps, the actual work is the same: write content that AI answer engines want to quote, make sure crawlers can reach you, and earn mentions elsewhere.

Want someone to run this assessment for you? Book a call.

Common questions

What is the best AI visibility tool?

It depends on which engines your customers use, how many prompts you need, and whether you want recommendations or raw data. Otterly has a low entry price, Ahrefs suits existing customers, and Profound targets enterprises. Test manually first to clarify your needs.

Are AI visibility tools accurate?

They accurately record what the engines answered in their sample, but that isn't the same as what your customers saw. Answers vary between runs and by user, so treat results as a directional trend rather than an exact ranking.

Can I track AI visibility for free?

Yes. Run 20–30 buyer questions by hand across the main engines each month and record the results in a spreadsheet. It takes around an hour and is enough for most small businesses to spot gaps and competitors.

How many prompts should I track?

Start with 20–30 that reflect real buying questions across different stages. Businesses with multiple services, audiences or markets will need more. Prioritise questions tied to revenue rather than adding broad prompts that are easy to win.

Have something worth building right?